gender identity and restrooms
Posted: Fri Apr 09, 2010 9:49 pm
First this is just ridiculous. Restrooms are separated based on biological characteristics, not by gender indentity. While I understand a transgender man might feel uncomfortable goign to the restroom with men or feel like they are being harmed by not being able to associate with those that share their same gender identity we really need to bring some sanity into the conversation. If you are a man with a female gender indentity, you are really different at least today. You are an exception and you basically need to get comfortable with that. To make you comfortable, should other people be forced to be uncomfortable en masse?
Clearly single occupancy bathrooms are the only long term solution if one is necessary at all. In thailand they have transgender bathrooms in their schools, but I doubt that would be enough to satisfy US critics.
Second, they start talking about diagnosis of gender identity as a criteria for decideing whether a biologically female could go to the men's restroom. It is beyond my comprehension why the state, medical profession or anyone else should be able to decide if you have a legitimate gender identity that qualifies you for using a particular restroom. When I gender identify myself as a bird, can I demand a special birds bathroom? Yes I know that makes no sense, but what limits us to 2 gender identities, male and female. In time I don't see how we can avoid some cutting edge researcher coming up with new ones.
http://www.foxnews.com/us/2010/04/08/ma ... oms-teams/
Clearly single occupancy bathrooms are the only long term solution if one is necessary at all. In thailand they have transgender bathrooms in their schools, but I doubt that would be enough to satisfy US critics.
Second, they start talking about diagnosis of gender identity as a criteria for decideing whether a biologically female could go to the men's restroom. It is beyond my comprehension why the state, medical profession or anyone else should be able to decide if you have a legitimate gender identity that qualifies you for using a particular restroom. When I gender identify myself as a bird, can I demand a special birds bathroom? Yes I know that makes no sense, but what limits us to 2 gender identities, male and female. In time I don't see how we can avoid some cutting edge researcher coming up with new ones.
http://www.foxnews.com/us/2010/04/08/ma ... oms-teams/